Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Angelica Machi Lazarin, Associate Professor, State University of Maringa, Brazil.

Reviewers:

(1) El Fadel Derradji, Badji Mokhtar University, Algeria.

(2) Ashraf El-ShamyNational Research Centre, Egypt.

(3) Munshi Md. Shafwat Yazdan, Idaho State University, Bangladesh.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Bibhabasu Mohanty, SAL Institute of Technology and Engineering Research, India.

(2) Claudia Irina Koncsag, Ovidius University of Constanța, Romania.

(3) Mohamed Said Mahmoud Mohamed Salem, Sanitary and Environmental Engineering Institute (SEI), Egypt.

(4) Sajad Ahmad Ganai, University of Jammu, India.

(5) Kanchan Bahukhandi, University of Petroleum and Energy Studies, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (El Fadel Derradji, Algeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Ashraf El-Shamy, Egypt) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Munshi Md. Shafwat Yazdan, Bangladesh) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Sheng Zhang, School of Mathematics and Physics, Bohai University, Jinzhou, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Abdelbasset Felhi, Carthage Univesity, Tunisia.

(2) Ömür Umut, Bolu Abant İzzet Baysal University, Turkey.

(3) David A. Oluyori, Ahmadu Bello University, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Ghasem Soleimani Rad, IAU, Iran.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.83/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Abdelbasset Felhi, Tunisia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Ömür Umut, Turkey) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (David A. Oluyori, Nigeria) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Danilo Costarelli, University of Perugia, Italy.

Reviewers:

(1) Mustafa Hasan Hadi, University of Babylon, Iraq.

(2) Ahmed A. Hamoud, Taiz University, Yemen.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) César Augusto Borges da Silva Reis, Tecnological Institue o Aeronautics, Brazil.

(2) Francisco Martínez González, Technological University of Cartagena, Spain.

(3) Suha Najeeb Shihab, University of Technology, Iraq.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Mustafa Hasan Hadi, Iraq) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Ahmed A. Hamoud, Yemen) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Daniele De Wrachien, Professor, State University of Milan, Italy.

(2) Dr. Muhammad Shehzad, The University of Poonch Rawalakot AJK, Pakistan.

Reviewers:

(1) Amal Abdel Wahab Khalil Plant Pathology Reseach Institue, Egypt.

(2) Adielle Rodrigues da Silva, Brazil.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) R.Bakiyaraj, Government Arts College (A), India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Amal AbdelWahab Khalil, Egypt) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Adielle Rodrigues da Silva, Brazil) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Orlando Manuel da Costa Gomes, Professor, Lisbon Accounting and Business School (ISCAL), Lisbon Polytechnic Institute, Portugal.

(2) Dr. Chen Chin Chang, Adjunct Professor, Hebei Normal University, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Aziz Benhamrouche, Ferhat Abbas University Setif1, Algeria.

(2) Subin K Jose, Christ College, India.

(3) Devika G, Government Engineering College, India.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.16/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Aziz Benhamrouche, Algeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Subin K Jose, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Devika G, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Yahya Elshimali, Professor, Charles Drew University of Medicine and Science, USA.

Reviewers: 

(1) H K Shreedhar, Global Academy of Technology, India.

(2) Bilal Abdullah Nasir, Northern Technical University, Iraq.

(3) Abdulhaq Hadi Abedali, Mustansiriyah University, Iraq.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Zogo Tsala Simon Armand, Higher Technical Teachers Training College-University of Ebolowa, Cameroon.

(2) Bentaieb Samia, University  of Ain Temouchent Belhadj Bouchaid, Algeria.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.66/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (H K Shreedhar, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Bilal Abdullah Nasir, Iraq) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Abdulhaq Hadi Abedali, Iraq) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Fang Xiang, International Business School, University of International and Business Economics, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Parul Bhatt Kotiyal, Forest Research Institute, India.

(1) Halliru Bilyaminu, Kano University of Science and Technology, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 9/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9.5/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Parul Bhatt Kotiyal, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Halliru Bilyaminu, Nigeria) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Roxana Plesa, Senior Lecturer, University of Petrosani, Romania.

Reviewers:

(1) Susana Sofia Pereira da Silva, School of Hospitality and Tourism, Portugal.

(2) M. Ravichandran, K. Ramakrishnan College of Engineering, India.

(3) Lok Raj Sharma, Nepal.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.16/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Susana Sofia Pereira da Silva, Portugal) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (M. Ravichandran, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Lok Raj Sharma, Nepal) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Chun-Chien Kuo, Associate Professor, National Taipei University of Business, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Meskat Ibne Sharif, ISCTE-University Institute of Lisbon, Portugal.

(2) Minati Rani Mohapatra, India.

(3) Firman Menne, Bosowa University, Indonesia.

(4) Gyanendra Prasad Paudel, Tribhuvan University, Nepal.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.75/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Meskat Ibne Sharif, Portugal) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Minati Rani Mohapatra, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Firman Menne, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_4 (Gyanendra Prasad Paudel, Nepal) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Der-Jang Chi, Chinese Culture University, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Liliana Rodrigues, University of Madeira, Portugal.

(2) Nawal Fadhil Abbas, University of Baghdad, Iraq.

(3) Lucian Lupu-Dima, University of Petrosani, Romania.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Nikolaos Papagiannis, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece.

(2) Novalita Fransisca Tungka, Universitas Sintuwu Maroso, Indonesia.

(3) Rosane Malvestiti, Federal University of Santa Catarina, Brazil.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.66/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_1 (Liliana Rodrigues, Portugal) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer review report_2 (Nawal Fadhil Abbas, Iraq) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer review report_3 (Lucian Lupu-Dima, Romania) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA