Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Faisal, Lecturer, Institute of Business Studies and leadership, Abdul Wali Khan University, Mardan, KP, Pakistan.

Reviewers:

(1) Arnaldo Esquivel-Fariña, Universidad Nacional de Asunción, Paraguay.

(2) Hikma Niar, Indonesia.

Additional Reviewers:

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.6/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Arnaldo Esquivel-Fariña, Paraguay) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Hikma Niar, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Kamarulzaman Ab. Aziz, Associate Professor, Multimedia University, Malaysia.

Reviewers:

(1) Saeeda Akbar, Community Medical Institute, College of Nursing, Pakistan.

(2) Cristhian Jhair Sánchez Uriarte, Perú.

(3) Amarnath Padhi, NIST Institute of Science and Technology, India.

(4) Bhushan A. Thakre, Dr. PDKV, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Tahir Jabbar, University of the Punjab, Gujranwala Campus, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Muhammad Azhar Bhatti, The Islamia University of the Bahawalpur, Pakistan.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.88/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Saeeda Akbar, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Cristhian Jhair Sánchez Uriarte, Perú) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Amarnath Padhi, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_4 (Bhushan A. Thakre, India) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Pratima Parashar, Pandey School of Science & Engineering, IILM University, India.

(2) Prof. Lei Zhang, Winston Salem State University, USA.

Reviewers:

(1) Ning Wang, College of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Shandong University of Science and Technology, China.

(2) Benjamin Yusuf Mailafiya, Nigerian Building and Road Research Institute, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Martazaev Abdurasul, Namangan Engineering Construction Institute, Uzbekistan.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Binu, KTU, India.

(2) K I Syed Ahmed Kabeer, Anna University, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.85/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Ning Wang, China) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Benjamin Yusuf Mailafiya, Nigeria) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Aleksandr Nikolaevich Sekisov, Kuban State Agrarian University, Russia and Institute of Construction and Transport Infrastructure, Kuban State Technological University, Russia.

Reviewers:

(1) Ramiro Cruz Durán, Universidad Nacional Autónoma De México, Mexico.

(2) Amos Wanene, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture & Technology, Kenya.

Additional Reviewers:

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Jige Sandipan Babasaheb, Sant Ramdas College Ghansawangi, India.

(2) Resti Fevria, Universitas Negeri Padang, Indonesia.

(2) Shashikant Bharatrao Shisode, Loknete Vyankatrao Hiray Arts, Sci & Com College, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.2/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Ramiro Cruz Durán, Mexico) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Amos Wanene, Kenya) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Dr. Sheng Zhang, School of Mathematical Sciences, Bohai University, Jinzhou, China.

(2) Prof. Francisco Welington de Sousa Lima, Natural Sciences Center, Federal University of Piaui, Brazil, Minister Petrônio Portella University Campus, Brazil.

Reviewers:

(1) Heni Sulistiani, Universitas Teknokrat Indonesia, Indonesia.

(2) Matheus Supriyanto Rumetna, Victory University Sorong, Indonesia.

(3) Ajayi Olusola Olajide, Adekunle Ajasin University, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Heni Sulistiani, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Matheus Supriyanto Rumetna, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Ajayi Olusola Olajide, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Fang Xiang, Visiting Professor, International Business School, University of International and Business Economics, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Deden Tarmidi, Universitas Mercu Buana, Indonesia.

(2) Ignatius Roni Setyawan, Universitas Tarumanagara, Indonesia.

(3) Madara Martin W.O, School of Business and Economics, Jaramogi Oginga Odinga University of Science and Technology, Kenya.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Emmanuel Osei Asiamah, Knutsford University, Ghana.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Mahesh Luthia, Chetana’s Institute of Management and Review, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.6/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Deden Tarmidi, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Ignatius Roni Setyawan, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Madara Martin W.O, Kenya) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Chun-Chien Kuo, National Taipei University of Business, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Kader, Mersin University, Türkiye.

(2) Akaraphun Ratasuk, Panyapiwat Institute of Management, Thailand.

Additional Reviewers:

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Olga Zlobina, University of Aerospace Instrumentation, Russia.

(2) Syed Sikander Wali, Comsats University Islamabad, Pakistan.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Kader, Türkiye) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Akaraphun Ratasuk, Thailand) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Rachid Masrour, Sidi Mohamed Ben Abdellah University, Morocco.

Reviewers:

(1) Neeta Kumar, India.

(2) Savan Tank, Swarrnim Startup and Innovation University, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Naresh Rambhau Dahegaonkar, Gondwana University, India.

(2) T.Jagadeeshwara Chari, Government Degree College (A), India.

(3) Umesh Pravin Dhuldhal, School of Life Sciences, Swami Ramanand Teerth Marathwada University, India.

(4) Vigneswara Rao A/L Gannapathy, Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka (UTEM), Malaysia.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.35/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Neeta Kumar, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Savan Tank, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Isidro Alberto Pérez Bartolomé, University of Valladolid, Spain.

Reviewers:

(1) Shashank D U, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Central Agricultural University, India.

(2) Siniša Franjić, Europe.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Bui Tuan Viet, Institute of Ecology and Biological Resources, Vietnam.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Shashank D U, India) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Siniša Franjić, Europe) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Daniele De Wrachien (Retired), The State University of Milan, Italy.

Reviewers:

(1) Yasodha T, Madha Engineering College, India.

(2) Askar Ghanbari Odivi, Sharekord University, Iran.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Maria Da Graça De Souza Lima, Brazil.

(2) Olumide Falana, Auburn University, USA.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.3/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Yasodha T, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Askar Ghanbari Odivi, Iran) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA