Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Ana Cláudia Coelho, University of Trás-os-Montes and Alto Douro, Portugal.

(2) Prof. Essam Hussein Abdel-Shakour, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.

Reviewers:

(1) Kholik Kholik, Universitas Pendidikan Mandalika, Indonesia.

(2) Deepa Bhambhani, Raj Rishi Govt Autonomous College, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Mohammad Irfan, Banaras Hindu University, India.

(2) V. Karthikeyan, Karpaga Vinayaga College of Engineering and Technology, India.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Kholik Kholik, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Deepa Bhambhani, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Revised_MS_v2_and_Feedback_v2 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Maria Ciurea, Associate Professor, University of Petrosani, Romania.

Reviewers:

(1) Hasroleffendy Hassan, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Malaysia.

(2) Poazi Deinmodei W. Francis, Niger Delta University, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Lalith Nimal Senaweera, Sri Lanka.

(2) Mahmud Bashiru, Federal University Gashua, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Hasroleffendy Hassan, Malaysia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Poazi Deinmodei W. Francis, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Ana Claudia Coelho, Assistant Professor, University of Tras-os-Montes and Alto Douro, Portugal.

Reviewers:

(1) Hozan Jalil Hamasalim, University of Sulaimani, Iraq.

(2) Tri Siswati, Poltekkes Kemenkes Yogyakarta, Indonesia.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Mohammed Mousa Atta, Sumer – College of Medicine, Iraq.

(2) Rafael Machado de Araújo Alves, University Federal of Paraíba (UFPB), Brazil.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Aqeel Ismael Gheni, Koya University, Iraq.

(2) Grishma  Kulkarni, Deccan College of Medical Sciences, India.

(3) Uttiya Jana, J. D. Birla Institute, Jadavpur University, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.3/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Hozan Jalil Hamasalim, Iraq) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Tri Siswati, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Dariusz Jacek Jakóbczak, Assistant Professor, Koszalin University of Technology, Poland.

Reviewers:

(1) Yusuf  Surajo, Federal University Dutsin-Ma, Nigeria.

(2) Prathap Soma, Bournemouth University, United Kingdom.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Abhijit Biswas, Assam University, India.

(2) Carlos Antonio Kornuta, Argentina.

(3) P B Savitha, Dayananda Sagar College of Engineering, India.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Pannangi Naresh, Vignan Institute of Technology and Science, India.

(2) Thangavel Murugan, United Arab Emirates University, UAE.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.3/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Yusuf Surajo, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Prathap Soma, United Kingdom) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Chen Chin Chang, Adjunct Professor, Hebei Normal University, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Dewi Ratih, Brawijaya University, Indonesia.

(2) A. Sankari, Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Dhiss Tesnim, ENIG, Tunisia.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 6.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Dewi Ratih, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (A. Sankari, India) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Revised_MS_v2_and_Feedback_v2 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Daniele De Wrachien, State University of Milan, Italy.

Reviewers:

(1) Firoozeh Chamandoosti, Iranian Research Institute of Plant Protection, Agricultural Research, Education and Extension Organization, Iran.

(2) I Gede Ketut Adiputra, Indonesia.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Virginia Meléndez Ramírez, University of Yucatan, Mexico.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.2/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Firoozeh Chamandoosti, Iran) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (I Gede Ketut Adiputra, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Angelo Paone, Liceo Scientifico Ettore Majorana, Pozzuoli, Italy.

(2) Dr. Ravi Kant Chaturvedi, Centre for Integrative Conservation, Xishuangbanna Tropical Botanical Garden, Chinese Academy of Sciences, P.R. China.

Reviewers:

(1) Saeed B. Nia, IUST, Iran.

(2) Abanikanda Jubril Olatunde, Bayero University, Nigeria.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Bahidin Laode Mpapa, Muhammadiyah University of Luwuk, Indonesia.

(2) Namita Gupta, BBAU, India.

(3) Ronak Yadav, Himgiri Zee University, India.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.35/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Saeed B. Nia, Iran) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Abanikanda Jubril Olatunde, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Revised_MS_v2_and_Feedback_v2 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Chun-Chien Kuo, National Taipei University of Business, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Muhammad Asif, Federal Urdu University of Arts, Science, and Technology, Pakistan.

(2) Seema Bhakuni, Doon Institute of Management and Research, India.

(3) Sadaf Sultan, International Institute of Islamic Economics, International Islamic University, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Kush Bhushanwar, Medi-Caps University, India.

(2) Muhammad Nouman Shafiq, Xi’an Jiaotong University, China.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Yousif Mousa Sabti, Universiti Utara Malaysia, Malaysia.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Muhammad Asif, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Seema Bhakuni, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Sadaf Sultan, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof. Chun-Chien Kuo, National Taipei University of Business, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Marjan Maali Tafti, Tehran University, Iran.

(2) Muhammad Aqib Shafiq, Ghazi University, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Michael A. Adegbite, Petroleum Training Institute, Nigeria.

(2) V Ram Naresh Kumar, Sagar Group of Institutions, India.

(3) Younes Nikkhah, University of Mohaghegh Ardabili, Iran.

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

(1) Azhar Khan, Abdul Wali Khan University, Pakistan.

(2) Deepali  Tomar, Himalayiya  University, India.

(3) Manas Ranjan Sahoo, Rairangpur College, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Marjan Maali Tafti, Iran) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Muhammad Aqib Shafiq, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. John M. Polimeni, Associate Professor, Albany College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences, Albany, New York, USA.

(2) Dr. Ridzwan Che Rus, Associate Professor, Sultan Idris Education University, Malaysia.

(3) Prof. Chun-Chien Kuo, National Taipei University of Business, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) Mustapha Ibrahim, Federal Polytechnic Damaturu, Nigeria.

(2) Laraib Javaid, The University of Agriculture, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

Additional Reviewers: (Comments received after deadline)

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.85/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Mustapha Ibrahim, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Laraib Javaid, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v2_and_Feedback_v2 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_3_v1 | File 1 | NA